Misha Collins - Paul Bernardo

Tess Harper - Molly Czehowicz

Leonard Kelly-Young - Dan Czehowicz

Alex Boyd - Nick

Cherilyn Hayres - Tammy Homolka

Kristen Swieconek - Tina McCarthy

Sarah Foret - Kaitlyn Ross

Patrick Bauchau - Dr. Arnold

Tony Denison  Det. Burows

Emilie Jacobs - Debbie

Zach DiLiberto - Doug

Brandon Routh - Tim Peters

Dave Michael Beaudrie - Police Officer

Danielle Burgio - Reporter

William Duffy - Det. Porter

Stephen Jared - Constable Nesbit

Ross Patterson - Steve

Diana Gitelman - Becky Wilson

Choppy Guillotte - News Reporter

Angie Hill - Juror

Sawn Hoffman - Det. Steve Kirby

Tanya Lemelle - Victim #3

Anna Pheil - Patricia

Jayme McCabe - Bartender

Rana McAnear - School Girl

Ron Brosh - Cop (unacredited)